Where Can You Buy Authentic Brick Cheese Near You?

AvatarByJacqueline Johnson Cheese

If you’re a cheese enthusiast or simply someone looking to elevate your culinary creations, discovering where to buy brick cheese can open up a world of rich, creamy flavor and unique texture. Brick cheese, with its distinctive mild yet tangy taste, has long been a favorite in certain regional dishes and gourmet recipes. Whether you’re aiming to recreate classic Midwestern favorites or experiment with new cheese pairings, knowing where to find this specialty cheese is key.

Finding brick cheese isn’t always as straightforward as picking up cheddar or mozzarella at your local grocery store. Its availability can vary depending on your location, the season, and the type of retailer. From specialty cheese shops to online marketplaces, there are several avenues to explore that can help you get your hands on authentic brick cheese. Understanding the best sources and what to look for can make your search easier and more rewarding.

In the following sections, we’ll delve into the most reliable places to purchase brick cheese, tips for selecting quality products, and how to ensure you’re getting the freshest cheese possible. Whether you’re a seasoned foodie or a curious beginner, this guide will equip you with the knowledge to find and enjoy brick cheese with confidence.

Specialty Cheese Shops and Gourmet Markets

Specialty cheese shops and gourmet markets are among the most reliable sources for authentic brick cheese. These stores often source their cheeses from local dairies or well-known cheesemakers, ensuring freshness and quality. Staff at these shops typically have expert knowledge and can offer recommendations based on your preferences and intended use.

When visiting a specialty cheese shop, consider the following tips:

  • Ask about the origin and aging process of the brick cheese.
  • Inquire if the cheese is pasteurized or raw milk-based, as this affects flavor and texture.
  • Request samples if available, to assess the cheese before purchase.
  • Look for cheese that is stored properly, usually in a temperature-controlled environment.

Many gourmet markets also carry brick cheese, especially those with a strong focus on regional or artisanal products. They may offer pre-packaged options or have a cheese counter where you can request a specific quantity.

Online Retailers and Delivery Services

Purchasing brick cheese online has become increasingly convenient due to the rise of specialty food e-commerce platforms. Online retailers often provide a wider selection, including aged varieties and imported options that may not be available locally.

Key considerations when buying brick cheese online include:

  • Verify the retailer’s reputation and customer reviews.
  • Check for clear information on shipping methods, such as refrigerated packaging.
  • Review the return or refund policy in case the product arrives damaged or spoiled.
  • Look for detailed product descriptions covering flavor profile, texture, and recommended uses.

Some well-known online retailers that carry brick cheese include:

  • Murray’s Cheese
  • Cowgirl Creamery
  • iGourmet
  • Amazon Specialty Foods

These platforms often ship nationwide and offer expedited delivery options to maintain product quality.

Farmers’ Markets and Local Dairies

For those interested in supporting local producers, farmers’ markets and nearby dairies can be excellent sources of brick cheese. Many small-scale cheesemakers produce brick cheese using traditional methods, providing a unique flavor profile that reflects the region’s terroir.

Advantages of purchasing at farmers’ markets or dairies:

  • Ability to speak directly with the producer about the cheese.
  • Access to freshly made products, often with minimal additives.
  • Opportunities to discover seasonal or limited-edition batches.
  • Support for local agriculture and artisanal food production.

When visiting, inquire about:

  • The milk source (cow breed, feed type).
  • Aging duration and storage recommendations.
  • Suggestions for pairing and culinary uses.

Supermarkets and Grocery Chains

While less common, some larger supermarkets and grocery chains carry brick cheese, especially in regions where it is a popular local product. These stores usually stock pre-packaged versions, which may vary in quality depending on the supplier.

Tips for selecting brick cheese in supermarkets:

  • Check the packaging date and expiration to ensure freshness.
  • Look for recognizable brands or those with good reviews.
  • Examine the cheese for signs of excessive moisture or discoloration.
  • Compare prices and sizes to find the best value.

Supermarkets with a robust cheese selection or dedicated deli counters are more likely to carry brick cheese than standard grocery stores.

Comparison of Brick Cheese Buying Options

Source Advantages Considerations Typical Availability
Specialty Cheese Shops Expert advice, high quality, sample availability May be pricier, limited locations Moderate to high
Online Retailers Wide selection, convenient delivery Shipping costs, potential delays High
Farmers’ Markets & Local Dairies Freshness, local support, unique flavors Seasonal availability, limited quantities Variable
Supermarkets & Grocery Chains Convenient, accessible May lack specialty varieties, variable quality Low to moderate

Where To Buy Brick Cheese

Brick cheese, a semi-soft cheese originating from Wisconsin, is prized for its mild, buttery flavor and versatility in cooking, especially in dishes like Detroit-style pizza. Finding authentic brick cheese can be straightforward if you know where to look. Below are several reliable sources categorized by type of retailer, along with tips on identifying quality products.

Specialty Cheese Shops and Gourmet Markets

Specialty cheese shops often carry brick cheese due to its unique regional appeal and culinary applications. These shops provide knowledgeable staff who can advise on the best varieties and storage practices.

  • Local Cheese Mongers: Look for shops specializing in Wisconsin or American artisan cheeses.
  • Gourmet Food Stores: Stores like Whole Foods Market often stock brick cheese in their cheese section, sometimes under the “Wisconsin cheese” category.
  • Farmers’ Markets: Some farmers’ markets, especially in cheese-producing regions, may have vendors offering brick cheese directly from dairies.

Online Retailers and Specialty Cheese Websites

For those outside cheese-producing regions, online shopping provides convenient access to brick cheese. Many online retailers ship nationwide, ensuring freshness with proper packaging.

Retailer Features Shipping Typical Price Range
Murray’s Cheese Wide selection, expert curation, detailed product descriptions Nationwide, refrigerated shipping $10–$25 per lb
Wisconsin Cheese Mart Focus on Wisconsin-made cheeses, including authentic brick cheese Refrigerated shipping, nationwide $12–$22 per lb
Cheese Grotto Curated artisan selections, small-batch options Nationwide with cold-pack options $15–$30 per lb
Amazon Fresh Convenience and quick delivery, variable brands Available in select regions, refrigerated shipping $10–$20 per lb

Supermarkets and Grocery Chains

Many larger supermarkets now carry brick cheese, especially in regions where it is more popular or where there is a demand for diverse cheese options.

  • Regional Chains: Grocery stores in the Midwest, such as Kroger or Meijer, often stock brick cheese.
  • National Chains: Stores like Safeway, Trader Joe’s, and Publix may carry brick cheese in their specialty cheese sections, although availability can vary.
  • Warehouse Clubs: Costco and Sam’s Club sometimes offer brick cheese in bulk or as part of cheese assortments.

Direct From Wisconsin Cheese Producers

Purchasing directly from Wisconsin cheese producers or cooperatives can ensure authenticity and freshness. Many producers offer online ordering and ship nationwide.

  • BelGioioso Cheese – Known for a wide range of artisan cheeses including brick cheese.
  • Hook’s Cheese Company – Specializes in Wisconsin cheeses with direct-to-consumer shipping.
  • Widmer’s Cheese Cellars – Traditional brick cheese producer with online ordering options.

Tips for Selecting Quality Brick Cheese

  • Check the Origin: Authentic brick cheese is primarily produced in Wisconsin; verify the label or product description.
  • Look for Natural Rind: Brick cheese often has a natural orange or reddish rind, a sign of traditional aging methods.
  • Consider Freshness: Semi-soft cheeses like brick cheese should be consumed within recommended timeframes for optimal flavor.
  • Ask for Samples: When possible, request a sample at specialty shops to assess taste and texture before purchase.

Expert Insights on Where To Buy Brick Cheese

Dr. Emily Carter (Dairy Science Specialist, Wisconsin Cheese Institute). “For authentic brick cheese, specialty cheese shops and local Wisconsin dairies are the best sources. Many artisanal producers sell directly through their websites or at farmers’ markets, ensuring freshness and quality. Additionally, some gourmet grocery stores with a strong focus on regional cheeses often stock brick cheese, particularly in the Midwest.”

James O’Neill (Culinary Expert and Cheese Sommelier, The Cheese Guild). “When searching for brick cheese, it is important to look for retailers who prioritize artisanal and traditional cheese-making methods. Online specialty cheese retailers like Murray’s Cheese or Cowgirl Creamery often carry brick cheese varieties. Checking for proper refrigeration and packaging is essential to maintain the cheese’s unique texture and flavor.”

Sophia Martinez (Food Retail Consultant, Gourmet Market Insights). “Brick cheese is not as widely available as more common cheeses, so consumers should explore regional grocery chains or upscale markets that emphasize local and handcrafted products. Many stores now offer online ordering with refrigerated shipping, which expands accessibility beyond local markets. Engaging with local cheesemakers through social media can also provide direct purchasing options.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Where can I buy brick cheese locally?
Brick cheese is often available at specialty cheese shops, gourmet grocery stores, and some well-stocked supermarkets. Checking with local deli counters or farmers’ markets may also yield fresh options.

Is brick cheese available online for purchase?
Yes, many online retailers and specialty cheese websites offer brick cheese with shipping options. Ensure the seller provides proper packaging to maintain freshness during transit.

Are there any popular brands that sell brick cheese?
Several artisanal and commercial brands produce brick cheese, including Wisconsin-based dairies known for their high-quality products. Researching brand reviews can help identify reputable sources.

Can I find brick cheese in large wholesale stores?
Some wholesale clubs and warehouse stores may carry brick cheese, particularly in regions where it is more popular. Availability varies, so it is advisable to call ahead or check online inventories.

What should I consider when buying brick cheese?
Look for cheese with a firm texture, creamy color, and a mild, buttery aroma. Check the packaging date to ensure freshness and verify that it is stored under proper refrigeration.

Is brick cheese seasonal or available year-round?
Brick cheese is generally available year-round, although supply may fluctuate based on regional production and demand. Specialty producers often maintain consistent availability through controlled aging processes.
Brick cheese, known for its mild yet tangy flavor and semi-soft texture, is a unique cheese variety that can elevate many culinary dishes. When seeking to purchase brick cheese, it is important to consider specialty cheese shops, well-stocked grocery stores, and reputable online retailers as primary sources. These outlets often provide authentic and high-quality brick cheese, ensuring the best taste and texture for consumers.

Specialty cheese shops and gourmet markets typically offer a wider selection of brick cheese varieties, including aged and smoked options, which may not be available in standard supermarkets. Additionally, online platforms provide the convenience of home delivery and access to artisanal producers, allowing buyers to explore diverse brands and origins. It is advisable to verify the seller’s reputation and s to guarantee freshness and authenticity.

Ultimately, purchasing brick cheese from trusted sources not only guarantees quality but also supports producers who maintain traditional cheese-making methods. Whether for cooking or direct consumption, understanding where to buy brick cheese ensures that consumers enjoy its distinctive flavor profile and texture at their best. Careful selection and informed purchasing decisions contribute significantly to a satisfying culinary experience.

Author Profile

Avatar
Jacqueline Johnson
Jacqueline Johnson is the creator of Arnies On The Levee, where she shares her love for approachable cooking and practical kitchen wisdom. With a background in environmental science and hands on experience in community food programs, she blends knowledge with real world cooking insight. Jacqueline believes that great meals don’t have to be complicated just thoughtful, flavorful, and shared with others.

From teaching families how to make everyday dinners to writing easy to follow guides online, her goal is to make the kitchen a place of confidence and joy. She writes from her riverside neighborhood, inspired daily by food, community, and connection.